Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) Mandates Arabic and Islamic Studies for Intelligence Wing to Address October 2023 Failures

In the wake of the devastating intelligence failures surrounding the Hamas attack on October 7, 2023, which resulted in 1,200 deaths and 251 abductions, the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) have embarked on a significant overhaul of their intelligence training programs. The IDF’s Intelligence Directorate, known as AMAN, has introduced mandatory Arabic language and Islamic studies training for all personnel, including those in technical and cyber roles, to bolster analytical capabilities and prevent future lapses. This initiative, spearheaded by AMAN chief Major General Shlomi Binder, aims to address critical gaps in cultural and linguistic understanding exposed during the October 2023 attack. By the end of 2026, all AMAN personnel will be trained in Islamic studies, and 50% will receive Arabic language instruction, marking a transformative shift in Israel’s military intelligence approach.

Background: The October 7 Intelligence Failure

The Hamas attack on October 7, 2023, was a catastrophic intelligence failure for Israel. Despite receiving information about Hamas’s attack plans as early as 2018, including a detailed 2022 report titled “Jericho’s Walls,” the IDF’s Military Intelligence Directorate underestimated the threat. Assessments wrongly characterized Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar as a pragmatist focused on maintaining civil control in Gaza rather than launching a large-scale attack. The IDF believed Hamas was deterred by the high cost of war and was primarily focused on rocket capabilities and limited infiltrations, not a ground invasion. This misjudgment allowed Hamas to exploit Israel’s underestimation of its operational tactics and cultural motivations, leading to a surprise assault that overwhelmed Israeli defenses.

Internal investigations revealed systemic issues, including a lack of understanding of radical Islamic culture, groupthink, and a failure of imagination among intelligence personnel. The absence of cultural and linguistic expertise hindered the IDF’s ability to interpret critical intelligence, such as Hamas’s multi-front war aspirations and regional dialects used in communications. These findings underscored the need for a deeper understanding of the enemy’s language, religion, and cultural context to enhance predictive and analytical capabilities.

The New Training Mandate

To address these shortcomings, Major General Shlomi Binder has mandated comprehensive reforms to integrate Arabic language and Islamic studies into the training of all AMAN personnel. Previously, such training was not compulsory, particularly for those in technological roles like cyber specialists in Unit 8200. Now, every soldier and officer, regardless of their position, will undergo Islamic studies training, with half also receiving Arabic language instruction. The goal is to ensure future commanders are fluent in Arabic and well-versed in Islamic culture, fostering “doubt and deep observation” to sharpen analytical skills.

A senior AMAN officer, quoted by Army Radio correspondent Doron Kadosh, stated, “Until now, we haven’t been good enough in the areas of culture, language, and Islam. We need to improve in these areas. We won’t turn our intelligence officers and soldiers into Arab kids who grew up in a village, but through language and cultural studies, we can instill in them doubt and deep observation.” This reflects the IDF’s acknowledgment that cultural and linguistic proficiency is essential for interpreting intelligence accurately and anticipating adversarial strategies.

Specialized Dialect Training

The training program includes specialized modules on regional dialects, particularly those spoken by the Houthis in Yemen and in Iraq. Intelligence personnel have faced challenges in deciphering Houthi communications, partly due to the widespread use of qat, a mild narcotic plant chewed in Yemen that distorts speech clarity. For instance, a June 2025 Israeli strike targeting a Houthi leader reportedly failed because the target was at a qat-chewing gathering, complicating communication intercepts. To address this, the IDF has recruited instructors from relevant communities to provide authentic dialect training, ensuring analysts can better understand local variations and cultural nuances.

Integration Across Training Stages

The reforms integrate Arabic and Islamic studies across all stages of intelligence training, from pre-enlistment programs to advanced officer courses. Research staff will be required to achieve Arabic proficiency as part of their basic training, ensuring that brigade and division intelligence officers possess high-level language skills and deep cultural insight. This holistic approach aims to create a culturally informed intelligence corps capable of analyzing complex regional dynamics.

Revival of the TELEM Program

To support long-term proficiency, the IDF plans to revive the TELEM program, which promoted Arabic and Middle Eastern studies in Israeli middle and high schools until its closure six years ago due to budget cuts. The program’s termination led to a sharp decline in Arabic education, reducing the pool of linguistically capable recruits. By reestablishing TELEM under Unit 8200, the IDF aims to foster early exposure to Arabic and Middle Eastern studies, preparing future soldiers for intelligence roles. This initiative reflects a broader effort to reconnect military needs with civilian education, ensuring a steady pipeline of culturally and linguistically adept personnel.

Establishment of a Dedicated Department

To oversee these reforms, the IDF is creating a new department dedicated to Arabic and Islamic education. This department will train not only translators and radio operators but also intelligence researchers, ensuring comprehensive cultural and linguistic immersion. The inclusion of cyber and tech specialists in this training marks a significant departure from previous practices, recognizing that technological roles also benefit from cultural context when analyzing data or communications.

Strategic Importance of Cultural and Linguistic Proficiency

Israel’s geopolitical context, surrounded by Arabic-speaking nations and facing threats from groups like Hamas, Hezbollah, and the Houthis, underscores the strategic necessity of Arabic proficiency and cultural understanding. Historically, the IDF has employed Arabic speakers in intelligence and de-escalation roles, but the October 2023 failures highlighted the need for broader and deeper expertise. The lack of cultural knowledge contributed to misinterpretations of Hamas’s intentions, such as viewing their avoidance of conflict with Islamic Jihad as a sign of restraint rather than strategic preparation. By embedding Arabic and Islamic studies into the core of intelligence training, the IDF aims to enhance its ability to anticipate and counter regional threats.

Addressing Misconceptions

Some sources have claimed that the IDF’s training includes mandatory study of the Quran specifically. However, reputable reports, such as those from The Jerusalem Post and Jewish News Syndicate, focus on Islamic studies and Arabic language training without mentioning the Quran. The emphasis is on understanding Islamic culture and regional dialects to improve operational effectiveness, not on religious texts per se. Claims of Quran study appear to be exaggerations, likely stemming from misinterpretations of the broader Islamic studies curriculum.

Challenges and Criticisms

While the reforms are ambitious, they face challenges. Achieving proficiency in Arabic, a complex language with diverse dialects, requires significant time and resources, which may strain the IDF’s training infrastructure. Additionally, the reliance on instructors from relevant communities raises questions about recruitment and retention, given the specialized nature of the instruction. Critics may also argue that the focus on cultural studies could divert resources from other critical intelligence functions, though the IDF maintains that these skills are integral to operational success.

Moreover, the reforms do not address all systemic issues identified in post-October 2023 investigations, such as groupthink and failures of imagination. While cultural and linguistic training can enhance analysis, fostering critical thinking and diversity of perspectives within the intelligence community remains a broader challenge. The IDF’s investigations emphasized the need for “black sheep” like Sergeant V, who challenged prevailing assumptions through deep cultural knowledge, suggesting that training alone may not suffice without a cultural shift in intelligence practices.

Conclusion

The IDF’s mandate for Arabic and Islamic studies represents a critical response to the intelligence failures of October 7, 2023. By equipping all AMAN personnel with linguistic and cultural expertise, the IDF aims to bridge gaps in understanding that allowed Hamas to execute a devastating attack. The inclusion of specialized dialect training, the revival of the TELEM program, and the establishment of a dedicated education department underscore the scale of this reform. While challenges remain, these changes reflect a strategic recognition that cultural and linguistic proficiency is essential for effective intelligence work in Israel’s complex regional environment. As the IDF implements these reforms, the success of this initiative will depend on its ability to foster not only technical skills but also the critical thinking and cultural insight needed to prevent future failures.

You Might Also Like:

Imran Reza Ansari Faces Backlash Over Alleged Remarks on Sahaba; Denies Insult

Brutal Honour Killing in Balochistan Sparks Outrage After Video Goes Viral; 15 Booked

Prince Alwaleed bin Khaled, Saudi Arabia’s “Sleeping Prince,” Passes Away After Nearly 20