Himachal’s Unique Tradition: Brothers Marrying One Woman and the Legal Status of Polyandry in India
Polyandry, where a woman has multiple husbands, is not explicitly recognized or regulated under Indian law but is also not expressly prohibited in most personal laws governing marriage. The legality of polyandry in India depends on the community’s personal laws, cultural practices, and the specific legal framework applicable to the individuals involved. Here’s a concise overview based on Indian legal provisions, particularly in the context of tribal communities in Himachal Pradesh:
- Hindu Marriage Act, 1955: This act applies to Hindus, Sikhs, Jains, and Buddhists. It mandates monogamy, stating that neither party can have a living spouse at the time of marriage (Section 5). While this implies one husband at a time, polyandry is not directly addressed. In practice, the Act does not recognize polyandrous marriages as legally valid under its framework. However, in some tribal communities in Himachal Pradesh, such as in Kinnaur and Lahaul-Spiti, polyandry (e.g., fraternal polyandry, where brothers share a wife) is a customary practice. These customs may be recognized under Section 2(2) of the Act, which exempts certain tribal communities from its provisions, allowing customary practices to prevail unless explicitly prohibited.
- Customary Law and Tribal Practices: In Himachal Pradesh, tribal communities like those in Kinnaur follow traditional practices where polyandry is socially accepted to preserve family land, resources, and lineage. The Indian Constitution (Article 371) and specific tribal laws provide some autonomy to tribal communities to follow their customs. If polyandry is an established custom in a community, it may be legally recognized for matters like inheritance or social arrangements, but such marriages are not registered as valid under modern statutory law.
- Other Personal Laws:
- Muslim Personal Law: Allows polygyny (a man having multiple wives) but does not recognize polyandry.
- Christian Marriage Act, 1872, and Parsi Marriage and Divorce Act, 1936: Both enforce monogamy and do not permit polyandry.
- Special Marriage Act, 1954: This secular law governs interfaith or civil marriages and mandates monogamy, making polyandry invalid.
- Legal Recognition of Polyandrous Unions: Polyandrous relationships in tribal areas are often informal or customary, not registered under statutory law. They may be socially valid within the community but lack legal recognition for purposes like inheritance, succession, or maintenance under mainstream laws unless supported by documented tribal customs. Courts may uphold such customs in specific cases (e.g., for property disputes) if they are proven to be longstanding and consistent.
- Criminal Law: Polyandry itself is not a criminal offense under the Indian Penal Code or its successor, the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023. However, if a woman enters a second marriage while the first is legally subsisting, it could be considered bigamy under Section 494 of IPC (or equivalent provisions in the new law), which is punishable unless the community’s customary law permits polyandry.
- Judicial Precedents: Indian courts have occasionally recognized tribal customs, including polyandry, in specific contexts like inheritance disputes. For example, in Labishwar Manjhi vs. Pran Manjhi (2000), the Supreme Court acknowledged customary practices of tribal communities in family arrangements, though not directly addressing polyandry. However, courts generally prioritize statutory monogamy unless clear evidence of customary law is presented.
Conclusion: In Himachal Pradesh, polyandry among tribal women, particularly in regions like Kinnaur, is a cultural practice rooted in tradition but not formally recognized under mainstream Indian marriage laws like the Hindu Marriage Act or Special Marriage Act, which enforce monogamy. Tribal customary laws may provide limited recognition for social and inheritance purposes, but such marriages lack statutory validity. If you seek specific legal recourse or recognition, consulting a local lawyer familiar with tribal customary laws in Himachal Pradesh is advisable.
You Might Also Like:
Imran Reza Ansari Faces Backlash Over Alleged Remarks on Sahaba; Denies Insult
Brutal Honour Killing in Balochistan Sparks Outrage After Video Goes Viral; 15 Booked
